Friday, February 20, 2009

We started today by sharing a bit of our own personal biographies including what experiences we’ve had that inspire our imaginations and influence our perspectives. I started by explaining I grew up skiing my entire life and that in the space of the chairlift, when forced to encounter a stranger, I could create any story I wanted about myself. A point in time, an encounter, an emptiness to fill, not only could I create a first person narrative different from reality, but I could also influence the stranger’s perspective about “me.” For me, the encounter in the ski lift and the blankness of perception which allows me to influence it, is a place to create story. Because most of my students are female, I also mentioned that in being completely covered in a parka and snow pants, I wasn’t judging immediately on my sex, on my physicality, which allowed even more room to influence and shape perceptions of myself. One student said she enjoyed imagining things while driving in a car and watching the scenery change. Another student said he enjoyed sleeping; he dreams often and in those dreams, is a fantastic possibility for interpreting reality and telling story.

I then had the students write about themselves in the first person narrative form, in the voice which just shared a piece of their biography. I asked them to never stop or pause, but to push themselves to keep writing (not worrying about mechanics or structure, free from personal censor).

Next, I asked them to, from that same first person narrative perspective they just wrote from, to write about how they perceived the person to their left. I asked them to consider writing about the character on their left based not only on what that person shared with the group, but also from their own perceptions about that person.

Then, I had the students consider the person on their right (the person who just wrote, from their perspective, about “you.”). I asked the students to write, from the first person narrative perspective, in the voice of that person, how they would characterize or perceive “you.”

For example, consider students:
A, B, C

So in the first phase, student A, B, and C, wrote from their respective perspectives about themselves. In the second phase, B wrote, from B’s first person narrative perspective about A as a character that B perceives. C did this for B. In the third phase of writing, B wrote in the voice of C (as they perceived or would image how C would write), from C’s first person narrative about perceiving and characterizing B. A wrote, in B’s voice, B perceiving and characterizing A.

This sounds complicated but the students got it. They were extremely mature about the exercise and very respectful about observing and characterizing each other (I told them to keep what they wrote to themselves). In the discussion after the exercises, I think the students really understood the incredible nature of perception and narration. I then explained the homework assignment: write two letters, one from one person’s perspective writing to another, and the response from that person writing to the first letter’s author.

One student mentioned that through an online program, she wrote a letter to herself when she got to high school which would be emailed to her when she turns 18. They got it! We discussed and considered how the “I” on paper can be from anyone’s perspective. Every time I write I, it does not imply that I am Trish Calvarese, and that in fact when I do that, it is a fiction and it is thus necessarily different from the reality of I, Trish Calvarese. In this way, the possibilities of perception and voice in storytelling and fiction are limitless. I suggested that in the homework assignment, they could even write a letter from “I” in the past to I in the future or present (or vice versa) because the experience “I” have is always changing and “I” am really never the same person.

I’m shocked with how well the students got this. They thought the exercise was “trippy” and they looked pretty confident in their understanding of it. We had a few minutes left so I asked two students to share a bit from the previous week’s assignment. The first student shared a lovely first person perspective speaking about salvation. I asked her who the “I” was whom was speaking and she said while writing it she wasn’t sure, but after doing the exercise, she realized it was her mother’s voice speaking at a time when she was the student’s age (15). The language was incredible, and to be honest, I got goosebumps- very passionate and moving. This was one aspect of the discussion from last time: passionate, rhetorical writing which is particularly effective in the political speech and which is told from a first person perspective. Then another student shared the first bit from her story. She was reluctant and said she was confused about the assignment, but with encouragement, she shared anyway. She wrote about a corrupt, incompetent mayor (who had the IQ of a 4th grader), who was in charge of all the money for a town and how he ruined it. Incredible! I explained to her that she really had understood the assignment. She had created a fiction that dealt with issues in reality, but in the fiction she created, in the fictional town and in the fictional character of the mayor, she could explore the issues of reality in the way reality can‘t. This was the other aspect of the discussion from last week- I had the students read “The Lottery” to get a better understanding of this point.

Another student said she had arrived at an ending in the story that she imagined but had arrived there in a different way than she anticipated, she wanted to know if this was okay. Ha! These kids get the issues of creative writing, and as artists, I think they know it intuitively. I told her it was more than ok and that when writing, though you can have an idea of where you want the story to go, you have to let evolve from what you write, because each sentence you write, eradicates all other possibilities. What is written down is the reality of the fiction, and building on sentence to sentence, natural patters and flows develop which, as an artist, one should be open to and aware of following.

I’m reading the rest of the students stories and am floored. One sounds like a short story from Vonnegut’s “Welcome to the Monkey House.” She writes, “The brokers (which in this case refers to those who are broke, bankrupt, lacking funds, financially insolvent) were confused.” Holy s***, these kids got things from the assignment and discussion I couldn’t even teach directly, but which I had hoped were implied. The only issue is that they don't really understand that they understand, the author of the above sentence wrote at the top of her story, "I did this very wrong." Using some examples from this assignment, I'm going to illustrate some of the things the students subconsciously understood from our first discussion. Seriously, a phenomenal experience all around, can't wait to see what they do with the homework assignment. Wish I had more time with them!

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Magical Adventure Part I

Friday the 13th- I came with a bag of candy ready to bribe any wee rapscallion to my favor as needed.

But before I even sat down, these fascinating young people embraced me with such a genuine, unadulterated enthusiasm and curiosity. Our time together made Hopkins workshops look like a visit to a drill-happy dentist in comparison (T. Davies’ fiction/fact and fiction/text excluded of course).

We began our discussion by considering the voice of a young, modern American’s perspective. We discussed the relevance of writing in our time, how and why it’s creative, to what purpose, and how the fields of creative writing are evolving. We considered what moves us, why we care to communicate, and how we do it effectively.

I asked the students to consider the rhetorical form of expression and creativity in the political speech. I asked the students to consider President Obama’s public speeches, his inauguration speech in particular. We discussed how it was effective, how it was creative, what its purpose was, and how it was achieved. I then had the students take some time to write a piece of their own inauguration speech, to write a quote or two they would want to be remembers for. I think asking students for their most indelible words on the spot is a great first challenge for students and sets a really interesting tone for the class.

Well let me just say President Obama could take some tips from these kids, their writing was disturbingly good. Some students talked about gender equality, about colorblindness, about art, others about freedom and happiness, a few even wrote short raps.

Next we read and discussed Shirley Jackson’s, “The Lottery.” We considered how the author’s objective in writing the piece was fictionalized compared to a political speech, but how she successfully conveyed a message or made a point. The students considered how, through rhetorical storytelling, by creating a fiction, a story grounded in the causes and effects of our realities, can be just as persuasive or moving as a political speech.

For homework, I gave the students a link to a draft of the Bailout Bill and asked them to take some thing from it which they could turn into a short fiction story (2 pages). I think this will be a good way to assess interest in skills and it’s a good point of departure which allows a lot of creativity. Students could either do that assignment or they could give me a complete inauguration speech. Every week for homework assignments I’m going to try to give students two options, either a fiction or an editorial based piece.

Time flew and by the end of class, I realized the bag of candy remained in my purse, un-opened.

Monday, February 16, 2009

Week One, Friday, February 13, 2009

I arrived at BSA a little nervous. I was particularly concerned about the reception the students would give me. I was mistaken. The students were great. They were so eager to learn and completely engaged. They were not timid, as I had expected. In fact, I gave one of the students a nickname: Mr. Enthusiastic. And in true Mr. Enthusiastic form, he accepted the name with open arms.

We began with introductions. I introduced myself and told them a little bit about my writing style (they were especially interested in my writing and asked me to bring them some samples). I had each student tell me their name, their concentration at BSA, what they hoped to get out of the class, and their favorite book or the last book they read. The answers they gave in response to the latter questions - class and book - were very sophisticated. As far as what they hoped to get out of the class, answers ranged from more focused pieces to less flowery words that seem out of place. Mr. Enthusiastic gave the most intriguing answer. He hopes the class can help him figure out why he writes what he writes and why he writes in the way he writes. At first, I told him his goals were maybe too psychological and probably beyond the scope of the course. But after we went back and forth I realized that I may have spoken too soon. Because I ended up telling him that the class may be helpful after all. The more writing he does, the more I believe Mr. Enthusiastic will become better acquainted with himself as a writer and answer these lingering psychological questions. He's a very dynamic kid; when he asked, rhetorically, "...who really wants to read a story about people who get along..." I knew I was going to get some interesting pieces from him.

I was very impressed with the books they highlighted. They ranged from Dante's Inferno, Kite Runner, A Thousand Splendid Suns, some Virginia Woolf...the list goes on. I was waiting for the inevitable Harry Potter answer, it never came. These kids are pretty informed.

I asked them what they thought the elemets of good storytelling were. They touched on the appropriates elments: good narrative, setting, conflict, climax, POV, etc. They did not miss a beat on this question either. We then moved on to the short story I had for them: Toni Morrison's Recitatif. We read the first page together in class and discussed the racial ambiguity of the characters. In Recitatif, Morrison is intentionally ambiguous about the racial identities of the two main characters. The story refers to the characters as "salt and pepper;" the reader inevitably spends the entire time trying to figure out who's salt and who's pepper. I'm still not sure. I was very impressed with the ease with which they approached the issue. When Mr. Enthusiastic commented that Twyla, one of the characters, was pepper because "...what white person names their child Twyla?" the class responded with comfortable laughter. I asked my students to finish reading the story at home. As a fun exercise I asked them to continue to look for clues on the racial identities of the characters. I also asked them to highlight a line or phrase that they found interesting and would love to emulate in their own writing.

For this Friday, I have asked them to write a one-page story. I told them they could take the story in any direction they pleased. I am most interested in where they are as writers.

I am very excited to read their stories. My class is filled with mostly actors; I can't wait to see how that translates on paper.

Sunday, February 15, 2009

Week One

I'm sorry this is so late, my internet is out and Comcast keeps telling me 'another hour or two'....for days.

The method of teaching writing as taught at Hopkins in IFP, is to start with the truth. We start with memoirs and move on to short stories. I'm not quite sure why. All it leads to is the inevitable post-IFP 1 back and forth between teacher and student: "This plot isn't strong enough/significant enough/is kind of boring" "BUT THAT'S HOW IT REALLY HAPPENED!" Truth-as-it-really-happened has no place in fiction. One of my students actually brought up the idea of truth in fiction. Fact and fiction is a concept that I've taken entire classes on and still haven't figured out completely, but I like to use a concept popularized by Stephen Colbert: fiction isn't true, but it is truthy. 

The problem with starting with memoir and moving on to a 5-page short story is that you never really sit down and look at what is actually necessary for a short story. What IS a story? What separates it from anecdotes? What makes it worthy of being written down and maybe published and actually read by somebody else? Writing Seminars frustrated me until my IFP 2 teacher introduced flash fiction. (Fiction that's 1000 words, max--an entire story.) I think its one of the most challenging things to write but also one of the most useful--because every word has to count. And if you practice enough flash fiction, when you begin to write longer stories you still keep that idea that every word does some kind of work, and it makes you a better writer. 

So that's where I started. We read some flash fiction. One, a short story called Sleeping by Katharine Weber, is about a girl hired to babysit a baby that doesn't exist. It is, despite its length, a very traditional story. We also read What I Know Of Your Country (and I forget the author of that one), but an interesting story told from the perspective of a man working in a call center in India. I think they liked it. I was torn between that one and one called The Orange, which is about an orange that is the god of the universe until it is eaten by a man who buys it at Safeway, but I'm glad I didn't go with that, as I think its a slightly more experimental story.

They've been assigned to write their own flash fictions. I've seen people in advanced fiction classes struggle with one or two page stories; I think they were grateful for the brevity of the assignment but I don't think they realize just how challenging it is. Next week I'm going to use those to teach them how to workshop.

Baltimore School of the Arts is a beautiful school. I know everyone there is a dancer or a musician or an artist or an actor, and I would love to try to find a way to incorporate that into the class itself. 

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Week 1

So, none of my students brought me an apple.
Not that I was really expecting it, but still. I put on my scuffed leather brown shoes, the French-cuff shirt with two polished Ceratotherium simum cuff-links, I combed my hair, I had a rough lesson plan in my head, I had print-outs. I even swore (tastefully) when the JHMI shuttle left me with two minutes to get from Center St. & St. Paul to the School for the Arts.
No apple!? Come on. Come on.
But seriously, folks (I’m here ‘til Thursday, tip your waitress), today was a blast. First off, this school is almost too awesome compared to my high school. My students were all enthusiastic and we had a lot of good discussions about our reading (see below)—definitely a good sign for the rest of the semester.
I have one ultimate goal that I want to teach: endurance. It’s a subject that we sort of broach in advanced workshops at Hopkins, but I don’t think we students of writing (we few, we happy few!) walk away with the right approach. I know that, when an assignment is coming up, I may read through my story once before submitting it (bad idea). Then the story is workshopped, I edit it and it’s submitted for a final grade. I understand the logistics of a course may demand this kind of treatment, but I think it can be taken in a negative direction.
A story is not completed once you’ve finished writing it. And a story is not completed after given an editing pass. Or two editing passes. The work of a story is not in generating the initial document, it is in the tweaking and hammering that follows—and I want to ensure that my students come to appreciate the art of—well, I guess finessing is the word—a long story that they’ve written.
To that end, this is what I’ve been envisioning: the students write four pages a week for five weeks, to generate a 20 page story. From there, I was going to have them edit each other’s work—in a workshop, hopefully—over the remaining weeks in the semester, making the draft edits, and going through two, maybe three revisions each. The net result may be a ten (or even three) page story. I’m surprisingly fine with that, as long as we all walk away from this class with a story that’s undergone a firey baptism. That’s how you know a story is strong, and that it is worth being read by someone. Sometimes this can get touchy, or painful—I know that I’ve walked away sore from some workshops in my four years, and I know plenty of others who seemed pretty mad at my contributions to their workshops. I also know really well how skewed a workshop can become when the instructor is as involved as the students are—the dynamics of the criticism can get fouled up (“Well, you are the only published writer in the room, Professor XXXX” [incidentally, we may want to consider hiring a Professor named XXXX, as it lends the department a degree of bad-ass street cred {but I digress}]). So I’m also going to try to sit back and let the students run their own workshop—lending guidance where I can, lest my young students descend into horrific savagery as evidenced in Lord of the Flies (a teacher’s necessary companion? YOU decide!).
I brought in two stories to read today—my two favorite stories, in fact. The first is the American classic, “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty.” For those that don’t know, it’s a short little wonder about a man who develops increasingly exotic day-dreams as a way of combating the unhappy and minutia-filled life he finds himself in. I really like this story for two reasons: firstly, Walter Mitty’s secret lives are symptoms we all share in life, maybe even more strongly by writers. Certainly escapism is one of the biggest draws to writing for a lot of people, and in this light, “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty” is (to me) what William Wordsworth’s “Preface to Lyrical Ballads” is to poetry: a writer (of escapism) is one who feels more deeply (about escapism) than his fellows, and as such is able to convey the sentiments of the world better than those around him. But that’s all theory, really. BOO theory (except where it validates my stance)!
Secondly, “Walter Mitty” is dear to my heart because (in my opinion) it is a story that only examines one aspect of fiction: the character. My students were quick to point out that nothing really happens in this story—we enter with Mitty unable to really escape his life, and we leave with the same impression. All the while, this story attracts so much attention because of dear old Walter—a doddering, possibly depressed child-like man with so much imagination and nowhere to put it. That’s the kind of approach that I want my students to think of when beginning their stories: what kinds of characters resonate with us, and why? How can this impact a story?

That’s all I got to report on for the first week. Next week, we’ll be reading the other story that I failed to get to (Isaac Asimov’s “The Last Question”). Here’s to a successful first day!

Wednesday, December 17, 2008

Weeks 9 and 10

Penciled, partially inked, inked - whatever stage the students' comics were at - they went up in the hallway outside of the room. They filled the wall, surging from character sketches on the left into a swell of their final comics on the right. As I placed the pages on the black paper, classes in single file flowed past me. Those that contained my students snagged on the display and artwork was pointed out with pride. Curiously enough, the Obama caricatures grabbed the most attention, and the three students that had won for best all held their quill and ink sets proudly.

I'd brought in my own quills, brushes, and ink along with small sheets of bristol for the students to try. Some of them were quite deft at it and inked their final comics this way. No spills - just some light splattering - the kids loved working with the medium. I'd meant to work with the ink for only half the class, but even the third graders were filled with an intensity of concentration so I let them use most of both classes (one of the reasons some final comics went up as pencils). Only a few of the students had enough patience for the quill which has to be held in a particular way to allow the flow of ink.

After ten weeks of working with the students, I felt happy to have allowed them to work in a form that's, for the most part, disregarded in the regular classroom. Upon reflection, I find this odd, because of all twenty-seven students only one did not enjoy cartooning. Most loved it and telling stories through sequences of pictures and words seemed to come naturally. Due to the workshop nature of the class and my desire to never assign homework, I had to allow much of the time to the students' work, but had I more than 10 weeks, I would have liked to go into even greater depth of character design. Looking at other comics more than we did and also giving the kids lists of character traits to illustrate would have been ideal.

I hope someone to follow me will do this again. The students were disappointed cartooning might not be offered in up-coming semesters, and I think there is just so much age-appropriate material out there and valuable skills to be learned from comics. The inherent organization in sequential art provides a ready framework for the brainstorming, revision, and final editing that are so important to the creative process.

Monday, December 8, 2008

Week 10

A week after our last class, I reflect on the semester. It was a learning experience, certainly. For us, the teachers, I think we learned that material isn't everything. For the students, well, I hope they learned some of the material. But even if they didn't, I hope they took away some inspiration. I'd be pretty happy if any of our students tried to write outside of class, and actually, I know some of them will.

At Thanksgiving dinner, I had a conversation with my Uncle about his experience teaching, because it's something I've been giving serious thought to lately. He teaches fourth grade in New York, but he's bounced around a lot, from junior high to high school, and he finally settled in elementary. He said the older the kids get, the more passionate about the material you, the teacher, have to be. But, at a younger age, you have to be passionate about the kids.

Looking back on our eighth graders, it was apparent some needed more guidance than others. The ingenuity squad were the easiest to handle. They were focused, but I also think they knew that this class was a break from the grind for them, so they took it in stride, and I think enjoyed it. The other team had more trouble. I wrote before about our dropouts. I think now that it's hard to take that as a failure on our parts. The class wasn't designed for them to miss their other class and not make up the work. But at the same time, I wish we could have shaken them and said, 'hey, this is really cool and important and you should take the time to get your other work done because you're really good at this and you have great subject matter and an ear for language and penchant for story telling.' That's kind of an impossible thing to tell someone, though. But our two soldiers who stuck it out understood this, I hope. Both were extremely creative, and we had pretty relentless fun with them. I hope we made it clear that they should keep this up. I think we did.

It's strange to think back now because there are so many things I wanted to convey, and now I'm mostly left saying, 'I hope I got through' in some way or another. Being a teacher is hard. But as a first experience, I would say this was really rewarding, and has made me rethink a lot of things, as I hope we inspired the students to do as well.

Monday, December 1, 2008

Week 10

The last class was today. It was bittersweet. On one hand, I am glad it's over. My Monday's this semester began at 7am when I woke up to prep for class and ended at 2am when I closed the library. These 20 hour days were really killing me. On the other hand, I did enjoy teaching. It was great to do something not college related, and I love the energy and enthusiasm of the kids. It really does hearken back to a more innocent time where things generally excited you in a way that cannot be recreated. Today, we were waiting for photocopies, and the kids got into a heated conversation about who would get eaten first if they got stuck on a desert island, and they were screaming and running around and it was great to see. I can't help but feel a conversation like that now would turn factitious and mean spirited so quickly. Of course, this also means that as a bitter old adult, I will look back on my college experiences as a time of innocence and wonder, where the possibilities were endless, and that is a scary thought.

Anyway, the last classes were fun. They were low key. We had them all write two page stories, expanding on what they did for last week if they wanted. We brought in Berger cookies and got them all sugar crazed before we did a final workshop. They were super excited, probably sugar high, and although they were fairly unruly it was still a fun discussion. They definitely got better at critiquing stories. I felt that by the end of the class they were simultaneously more critical and more understanding. And a few of them seemed generally interested in writing. They really put a lot of time and effort into it, and seem to have the interest to continue it. I never really did that and I wish that I had. I hope that this class lays the groundwork for some of them to pursue the arts in some form.

On a funny side note, I do not understand teen literature. It really seems to appeal to the lowest common denominator and it also does not seem to bother the readers one bit. I moved past teen literature very quickly, so I never realized it, but all of these kids brought in books each week and flipping through them gives a quick glimpse at how god awful they all are. Twilight is the ultimate example. Every kid in the class has read it, but I picked up a copy today that one of the kids brought and started laughing out loud at how awful it was. It was like erotica fiction for tweens. It was full of "His piercing eyes" and "His windblown hair" and "He pulled me in for a kiss before I could get away." If all else fails I am going to write teen fiction. All you have to do is write the dirtiest thing you possibly can in the most innocent language you can muster. And as far as I can tell, these kids are the only people who buy books in this day and age.

In the end, we gave all the kids our e-mail address. I told them that they could e-mail me about whatever, whenever. I said I would read stories, answer questions, give advice or college tours or just generally keep in touch. They all wrote down our e-mails so we will see if we actually get responses, but even if we don't, I can definitely say that it was an enjoyable experience all around.

Tuesday, November 25, 2008

Weeks 7 and 8

My Week 9 was canceled so I'll be holding it tomorrow instead.

Most students have finished their pencils, some have finished ink, and a few have only just finished penciling a first page. This was to be expected for fourth grade since they had a field trip that interfered with the class, but not from the third grade. I put as much iciness into my voice as I could and told a second third grade student that it was a privilege to be in the class and that if the chit chat continued to prevent her from getting work done I would need to speak to Frankie. I'd already had to do that once, and the first student promptly moved herself to the other table to keep herself from the temptation to gossip. The second student turned red and finished an entire page in two minutes.

I don't like to have to be the disciplinarian (especially one that nags) but if I have to do the "I'm the boss" act I'd rather have it short and effective. I can't imagine I'm feared but I think the "threat" was intimidating enough that I won't have to give it again.

At the beginning of each Week 7 class, I passed out two pages, one with five or so photographs of Obama, the other with caricatures of him. I told the students they would have a little time each week to work on the caricature and that we'd vote for the best one as a class in Week 9. I bought 3 combined ink pot/quill kits as prizes.

Frankie had found me extra long paper so I penciled the guidelines onto about sixty or so of these for Week 7. These consisted of a border and then a horizontal gutter in between the top and bottom panels. The gutter I made precisely 1/4'' and required that the students use rulers to keep the 1/4'' gutter consistent throughout the comic. I was a stickler about this and made more than one of the kids erase or start over.

Though they had more freedom to decide on the panel size, I wanted to emphasize that taking the extra time to do a neat layout would help their artwork pop. One of the students that ignored me (despite my instructional diagram on the board and my demonstrations to each of the tables) was one of those that I asked to erase and redo. She did a much neater job the second time and the final layout looked professional. I'm hoping that all of the students can appreciate how impressive the level they are working at is. I'm excited for the hall display because it will show this.

Tomorrow, for the students that have already finished their entire comic, I'm going to sit at one of the tables to do an inking demonstration. I'm bringing in a pot of my Sumi ink and brushes and letting the kids try for themselves. I'll rotate in the students that are still working so they will get a chance too, but under the condition they are working efficiently (I'm looking at you third grade).

I had told the students we would be doing flip books in Week 11 but without that extra week I'll have to do my best to squeeze it in to Week 10. At this point, at least a third or so of the students will need all of Week 9 and possibly some of Week 10 to finish their comics. I'll will have a better idea after tomorrow.

Sunday, November 23, 2008

Week 5, 6, 7, 8

Week 5 no one brought in their stuff to workshop, which was really disappointing. Instead we read "Franchise" and considered basic elements of setting- Aidan did the who what when where why + how equation. This was followed by a disinterested discussion of the ways in which these forms work. But things got a little bit interesting when our kids questioned the order of these tenets (and how many are needed in a successful beginning. It was hard to say, but we thought we should tell them that they needed to focus a lot on one of these details of setting, but to make sure to include the other details (it was hard not to suggest to just let them come, but we thought it better to insist on including them explicitly).

Week 6 we read "Franchise" aloud. I also got a fair number of poems from each class, which I looked over and gave comments on. Interestingly here, I found it problematic giving comments on the slam poems that the kids had done in another class (but which I accepted to look over, still). The slam poems were very emotionally charged, and I was careful to make practical suggestions, mostly thinking about how best to form the emotions of the poems and best deliver the knockout punch that slam poetry wants. But the form is troublesome for me- I've never been taught formally about slam poetry, though I've heard it before. The form itself seems to deny a straightforward way of reading it. Likewise, the form seems to thrive on a reckless abandon of formality, careful architecture, and like a beat poem, strive to deliver the experience fast and hard.

Some of the other corrections I made were easier because the poems were either free verse (not slam) or in the sonnet form. Free verse is difficult to correct in the way that slam poetry denies a form, though explaining the 'form' of free verse is extremely difficult (because there is a form, certainly). Instinctively, I tried to correct rhythmic problems, grammar, or course, and ways in which ideas ought to be connected and punctuated. Free verse is not the total chaos, though it can thrive in abstraction.

Week 7 we read "A Good Man is Hard to Come By." Aidan didn't touch on the question of racist language, which arose in the stories we read both in Week 7 and Week 8. We were extremely proud of our students for handling these stories in such a mature manner. But in both Flannery O'connor's story and Hemmingway's "The Killers," racist language can be telling of both the setting and the condition of the characters. In the event that the students confronted us about the offensive words in O'connor's story, we were prepared to justify the language's use by talking about the character's fate, and the ultimate redemption of good taste (and non-racist language). But in "The Killers," both of the killers go back and forth calling the cook of the lunch counter by his name and his common slur. The killers are more base characters than O'connor's grandmother, and their language reflects their class. It also somewhat reflects the common tongue of the time. There is no redemption for the killer's offenses at the end of the story, but besides the smear, the character Sam is treated no differently than the other prisoners. Obviously these words are inexcusable, but creative writing also offers a place for the most base of base human emotions. Racism is a tricky issue, but like I said, our students handled these powerful stories responsibly.

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Weeks 6, 7 and 8

Okay, you may be wondering why there are three weeks worth of info in this one post, but weeks 6 and 7 were not incredibly eventful... a lot of class time was allotted to working on their new pieces. This week (week 8) my class was canceled by Frankie (feel better!). Anyway, here's a recap of weeks 6 and 7:

On week 6, the kids came in and were excited to start the second project. I told them that this time they could write on a genre/topic of their choosing-- my only request was that they take some extra time to think about character development. This was because a lot of their ghost stories were very creative, but the characters were a little flat (I guess there's a lot going on in ghost stories what with all the vampires and psycho clowns, so there's less room for character development, but I wanted it to be addressed in the second project). I told them that rich, round characters were the aim of this project, though they could choose the topic and setting for those characters themselves.

To give them a head start on this, I gave them a list of questions to ask themselves about their characters. I put these on the board and gave them the option of answering these questions as a brainstorming exercise or, if they felt they had enough of a handle on the concept, just starting their own brainstorm or starting their story. I always like to lecture them a little bit about a lesson and give them a practice exercise, but I don't make it mandatory, because if they already have their ideas worked out I encourage them to work freely.

Here are some of the "Ten Questions for Creating Characters":
1. Where does your character live?
2. Where is your character from originally?
3. What is your character called (I explained that names are important and they say a lot... a character named "Smelly McGarbage" better not be a compulsive cleaner unless you want the story to be ironic)
4. What kind of childhood did he/she have? (Because, I told them, a character who was raised in a pig pen with wolves and sheep will behave differently than someone raised in a normal house)
5. ...

Anyway, the kids came up with some great ideas. I had mentioned "The Cat in the Hat" as an example of a good story that works because of creative characters... the book really wouldn't be about much if the Cat was boring, not well developed, etc. One girl got the idea from this to write a novel about Thing 1 and Thing 2 (from the book)... they were some little creatures that tagged along with the Cat. Only in her story, they're child slaves to the Cat and they're on a mission to get a paycheck out of him. No joke. I also met individually with each student to make sure they have an idea in mind, and for those who were stumped I helped them generate some ideas by asking them things like, "what's your favorite song? Why do you like it? What lesson does the song teach, and how could you make a character who lives by that lesson or needs to learn it?" (this resulted, in one case, in a story about a flea who lives on the back of a very hairy man and is too afraid to go out and live somewhere else, a change that is forced when the man shaves his back)

They spent the rest of week 6 working on those stories. Then on week 7 I handed out their prizes for the scary stories (I settled on personalized creative writing journals... I found packs of 10 for cheap on a teacher supply website). They each got a different award for those stories, but the prize for the best story from the second batch will be bigger because there will only be one winner per class (I have a prize in mind but I'm not sure yet). The rest of that class was also spent writing, though I talked a bit about revisions and told them that Week 8 would be spent on a full revision workshop (looking at the copies of their stories I gave back), which would give them a chance to consider changes on their first project while I took home their new drafts and gave feedback on the new projects. This will be pushed to next week, and hopefully by then they'll have a good chunk of writing ready for me to look over.

Monday, November 17, 2008

Week 7 and Week 8

A double posting for this epic week. I will divide it by the classes. In the first class in week 7, we had a long discussion about A Good Man Is Hard To Find. They loved it and they got into a heated discussion about who was to blame for the murder of the family. Some said the Grandmother, others the killer. They went back and forth for a while and I tried to explain the concept of Moral Luck to them which got them even crazier, but they really seemed to enjoy it. I told them they should all become philosophy majors if they really liked that sort of thing. After that, I gave them a quick lecture on Freytag's Pyramid and we used the structure to dissect A Good Man to answer some questions about whose story it was, multiple climaxes, etc. After that, we did a writing exercise. We had them each write 2 different first sentences of a story. Then we collected them and handed them out so they had each others. Then we told them the assignment for the next week was to write a new paragraph using one of the first sentences. They were really excited about the assignment. We also gave them the Hemingway story The Killers to read for the next week.

In Week 8 we started out by having them read their paragraphs. A lot of them went in completely different directions than what the sentence said. Most of them turned out fairly nonsensical but there was one awesome one. The girl's sentence was something like "Nina was getting her nails done for the second time that week." So for the second sentence of the story she wrote "Sophie put down the manuscript. She wasn't sure how much longer she could read stories like this, about such vain characters." It was really funny and creative how she wrote around a sentence she hated while still incorporating it. After that we talked about The Killers. They all hated it and we spent more time explaining what happend than talking about how it still conformed to Freytag's Pyramid, which was my original intent. I have never seen Hemingway lambasted so harshly. He gets no love from the 8th grade set. After that we talked about forms of Direct and Indirect Characterization. Then we had them do a writing excercise where they came up with a character and had to write down the name, age, place of birth and five characteristics. They really liked this excercise and came up with some outlandish things. It's funny to note how adulthood is characterized by seething desperation both by 8th graders and Seniors in College. Some things never change I suppose. We gave them the first real writing assignment this week. We told them to bring in a page long story about whatever they want, as long or short as they want as long as it does not go over a page. They all seemed pretty excited about that.

For the second class, we gave up on giving them reading. They never do it, they put up no pretenses about doing it, so we abandoned it. In Week 7 we tried to give them a lecture on Freytag's Pyramid, but they really were not having it. They said they knew it already and then could not explain it, then stopped paying attention all together. Eventually we had to yell at them and say that we were sick of the interruptions. It was the first time we got angry at them so it settled them down. After that, we tried to come up with a writing excercise to keep them busy. We played the game where we circled pieces of paper and everybody wrote a sentence to continue the story. They all ended in violent murders. It was a bust but they were really really enjoying it. As we left the thought that we were really just babysitting instead of teaching crept into mind and made me marvel yet again how teachers, especially English teachers, can do it.

Week 8 in the second class was non-existent. Apparently the kids had recieved quarter report cards the week before. We were met in the door by a mutiny of children. They all said they were failing their classes and it was because of their Mondays with us. Tom said that was ridiculous and they should sit down, but they kept protesting. After listening to them for a while I said, "Look, nobody is making you be here," and literally before I could finish my sentence they all grabbed their stuff and ran out. It was really dejecting. They had no desire to continue with us. There were two kids left, and we told them that if they wanted, we would do the last few weeks of class with them. Both of them wanted to continue so we gave them the same page assignment. It was the two that participated the most so perhaps it is for the best, but it was still disheartening to know we cannot even entertain 8th graders. They spent the rest of the time working on their stories. I hope they are good because they are going to be the focus of the workshop next week.

Sunday, November 9, 2008

Week 6

The Hopkins crunch is starting. I have literally had not time since Monday to post, as the academic stars are aligning to destroy my sleep cycle completely. But I figured I should get it done before we have another class tomorrow and I forget completely what happens. We spent the last class reading "Franchise" aloud because none of the kids had actually read it. It took way more time than I had anticipated it would. After we finished it they wanted to discuss it, but because we wanted to workshop we only talked about it briefly. They really liked it although some of the kids were too practical for their own good and had a hard time suspending their disbelief to think that things could actually be that way. We talked a little about the rules of science fiction, how it must build off the world we know for orientation, how much of science fiction is satire, etc. They seemed to enjoy it. After that we workshopped two of the poems. Both were very good. One kid tried a sonnet and even though the meter was off he stuck to a syllable count and a rhyme scheme. It was really encouraging that he put so much effort into the poem. The other girl did a free verse poem about nature. She had a lot of great images. She is the most talented writer in the first class. Her comments are always extremely insightful and her poetry is great, but she likes to sit in the back of the class and refuses to engage unless we force her to, so it's a struggle to get her to participate. We gave them "A Good Man Is Hard To Find" by Flannery O'Connor to read for this week. Although the theme is a little lofty it's an easy read and I figured they need some sex or violence to keep them engaged. I can only hope they actually do the reading this week. My plan for tomorrow is to lecture on Freytag's pyramid and basic plot structure and identify that in A Good Man. If they didn't read it again I am not sure what we are going to do. The second class was on a field trip so we didn't hold class. Their schedules are so wacky, but it was for the best since they were a class ahead and now we are back to where we should be. We'll see how tomorrow goes. I just really hope they do the work.

Tuesday, November 4, 2008

Weeks 5 and 6

I write this post on the eve before Week 7 as I watch the election results. I believe tomorrow's class will be kicked off with a lesson in caricature of either a losing or winning candidate.

The last two weeks have been devoted to brainstorming and planning out final comics. I lectured briefly at the beginning of each class about how to make a comic readable. I answered questions ranging from how to draw one-point perspective to how to spell "vacuum."

Most of my interaction with the students occurred when I sat with each table and discussed each student's work individually. Some ideas needed to be flat out vetoed: one girl wanted to draw a comic about a man and woman fighting over a piece of hair they find in the cushions of a couch. Even wackiness has to have some sort of logic that makes sense within its own realm. I didn't hesitate to reject an idea that the student couldn't defend with more than a shrug. I want them to get a sense of being able to let go of the "first thing that popped into their head" if it's not working or doesn't offer enough of a satisfying narrative. Again, I realize these expectations are high but as these last two weeks have progressed the students have been increasingly self-motivated and self-critical with the realization that I will not accept work that does not have a clear direction.

Week 5 I passed out a page demonstrating the range of characters from the picture plane (abstract shapes), reality (accurate and detailed characters), to meaning (language, symbols, and icons): http://www.chass.utoronto.ca/~mfram/Media/0505-UC-triangle-all.jpg

Though the subtleties of the argument were a bit beyond what most of the students could understand, the students were able to see how much forgiveness cartooning allows for character design and that drawing a realistic looking character isn't always desired. Some of the students who worried that they couldn't draw well enough relaxed and accepted characters that fell closer to the meaning realm.

Week 6 I passed out a packet that included three pages from Scott McCloud's Understanding Comics on panel-to-panel transitions including moment-to-moment, action-to-action, and aspect-to-aspect among others: http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1246/865762550_ba835e9123_b.jpg

I want to make sure that the students don't assume that their readers can read minds and need to slow down their story-telling at times to show an event explicitly. In addition, I want them to think about what that "gutter" between two panels means. When I suggested it contained the space-time continuum their eyes widened but I took that as a sign of epiphany.

For tomorrow, I've recreated comic book page guidelines so that the students will have enough freedom to design their own panels but also insure a border and a standard for straightness. I also went down to Plaza Artist Supply to find better pens. The ones I chose are PlumeII in black with a paint-brush style tip on one side and a fine point on the other. The fine-point permanent markers the students had used for the trial comics were frankly awful, and I'm hoping the effect of the new pens will be much closer to real ink. Though I don't think anyone will finish penciling the two to three pages tomorrow, I do want to have them on hand.

Before inking I'd like to do an in-class critique of the pencils by table. I want the students to trade their pages and try to read the comics. This will help insure the students are accountable for clarity and an understandable narrative structure.

Looking ahead, I foresee the students completing the inking in Week 9. The art teacher has given me an entire wall in the hallway outside her office to display the students' work. Not only is this a great way to show off their efforts, it will able be good publicity for the program. I'd like the rest of the faculty to see how sophisticated and smart cartooning can be.

Week 5

I know, I know, it's week 6 now, but I wanted to read the majority of the scary stories that my kids handed in before reporting back on the progress of the course.

I was definitely floored by their talent, but more so by their enthusiasm. Many of them volunteered to read their stories at the Halloween party (during which I gave them entirely too much candy and chocolate fudge cake, a realization I came to when one adorable student told me in an abnormally high pitched and jittery voice, "I'm so hyper right now I have a science test next period hahahah funny right can I have more Reeses?") Nevertheless I was really happy to see that they are all (ok, 90% of them are) really passionate about their creative writing. Really, this is the greatest thing I could accomplish as a teacher in this course and I feel like my purpose in being there is really being fulfilled; I'm getting them as excited about writing as I was when I was that age, at times furiously writing down ideas as they came to me, eager to share my work, and enthusiastic about assignments to the point where I didn't really view them as homework anymore (I told all my kids that they don't have to work on the stories at home if they don't feel like it, but 95% of them did work on them at home, many of them typing the stories up for me). The bottom line is, yes, a lot of these kids are exceptional writers, both in the morning class and the afternoon (Ingenuity) class, but more importantly at least in my eyes, their pieces are heavy on creativity and they're loving writing, which is what I want for them in this course.

A good example of this came from one of the students in the morning class... I hadn't read any of her work before this because she didn't turn in the optional first assignment (those fairy tales were really just a warm-up so I told the kids they didn't have to submit them if they didn't want to), but she was eager to read her scary story in class during the party. Not only is she a great writer-- great sense of humor in her work, nice handle on how to build suspense and just all around smart about how to construct a good story, but I could really tell she was having fun writing this. Here's a little taste from her scary story, "Stay Away From The Fair":

Then I saw him. The psycho clown.
"Hey there, you're in quite a predicament aren't you?" He asked. I said nothing. "Aw, lets be friendly, shall we?" He said. He appeared right next to me.
"I could help you out, you know," he said. "You see these creatures and ghouls? They're real, my friend."
"I'm not your friend."
"Now, now, now. Don't be that way; your worst enemy could be your best friend. But then again your best friend could be your worst enemy. Which makes them your best friend again. Which makes them your worst enemy, which..." He looked at me. "Complicated, isn't it? Well enough chat, let's get this over with." He grew fangs that went below his chin.

(That student's name is Megan Artis)

I got lots of stories that also incorporated the things that matter most to kids that age... I found it funny that another post in the blog mentioned kids who talked about pizza and skateboarding in their poetry; as I have 2 boys and 14 girls in total for my two classes, most of the stories have some elements of popular crowd, nerds, jocks, etc. It's funny how they'll insert these social classifications into even a ghost story; in one student's piece the evil witch/villain was actually an "uber-popular" and "uber-mean" girl at school, aided by her father, who is the principal of the school.

Finally, there were those students who were brilliant with language. One student in the morning class gave me this:

He flicked a glance at the sky, which was a deepening blue-violet. The full moon gleamed above the woods and he shivered slightly, even with the pleasant autumn mildness.
He crossed the bridge, hesitantly testing each board with his foot... Once he reached the other side of the bridge he saw Mandy there, awaiting him. Her in those beaten-up white sneakers, Band-aids adorning her legs every few inches.

(That's from Breea Wallace-Holland)

And those are supposed to be the REMEDIAL kids??

I haven't finished reading all the stories (and awarding prizes for them), but I'll post some more thoughts once I do. In the meantime, what are some good prizes for kids? I was thinking of getting them some cool writing journals or something but I welcome other (inexpensive) ideas. My friend Chris didn't like my idea to get them a book (I was thinking "Ender's Game"); he informed me that "if my teacher had given me a book as a prize when I was a kid I would have probably hit her with it." So suggestions are welcome.

I can't wait to see what the kids come up with for their second project, which is to come up with their own ideas/genres for a story (each student will meet with me individually to discuss it). I'll post a bit on that once my classes meets tomorrow morning.

Oh, and question-- I know these finished stories are supposed to appear in an anthology; is there a page limit? Cuz I've got some writers who need limits imposed if you don't want to read a lot, hehe.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Week 4

Just a quick note on week 4, which I neglected to post earlier.

When I met with my kids last week I was originally planning to talk about character development (as it seemed that this was the greatest challenge for many of the students in their fairy tales), but then I came to an astonishing realization..... week 5 is the Halloween scary story party/reading/candy feast! Only one week left to finish the scary stories!!

So character development had to take a back seat. I gave the students almost all the class time to work on their stories, with the exception of some time to go over issues with the fairy tales (most of them little things, but I wanted them to understand the comments I wrote on their pieces). I was delighted to find that many students had been working on their stories outside of class-- one girl was up to NINE pages, back and front (she is in the morning class and she is very talented and creative). Several students had already finished their stories. I had the pleasure of reading the finished draft from another very talented student in the afternoon class... she had put together a great piece that sounded straight out of the Twilight Zone, about a girl who starts disappearing bit by bit as a curse takes over her. I can't wait to see what the rest have in store for me on week 5... I'll post soon about the party and the first drafts of the ghost stories!

Monday, October 27, 2008

Week 5

Wow, week 5 already. The time certainly goes by fast. We missed two weeks of the class (One their fault, the other ours) so we were forced to end poetry quicker than expected. Last class, we gave each group the assignment of writing either a sonnet (16 lines) or 20 lines of free verse. We came in today expecting to spend the class period workshopping and and nobody had done the assignment. In the advanced class two girls were furiously scribbling down lines as we walked it. It was completely frustrating. Our lesson plan was shot and we had nothing to do with them, coupled with the sheer insult of realizing that we have not garnered enough respect from the kids for them to do their simple assignment. We begged and pleaded for them to finish it for next week and after that we sort of flew by the seat of our pants for the rest of the time period. I had photocopied the Isaac Asimov short story "Franchise" for them to read for next week. They all seem to be politically inclined (a testament to the historical aspect of the election) and I figured this would be a nice topical introduction to fiction. The story is set in a future where each election year one person is hooked up to a machine and asked questions, and the answers to the questions determines the way the electorate would vote given the choice. We read the first paragraph in class and I lectured a bit on what the first paragraph is supposed to accomplish. I likened it to a newspaper article. It has to answer the five W's: Who, What, Where, When and Why. Then we talked about how the Asimov story did this and we had them write a few lines about where they think the story was headed and then a second paragraph of the story thinking about what direction it is heading it. It was interesting, a lot of the kids disagreed with the idea that the first paragraph had to do anything at all. They leveled a ton of charges against this idea. "What if you never name your character?" "What if the main character dies?" "What if the plot starts in the middle and then flashes back so you don't know where they are?" I implored them to go back and read stories like that and see how there is some basic orientation done to make the story readable, and that a hallmark of bad writing is throwing a reader into the plot without basic information. They seemed skeptical but I think ultimately they accepted the idea. It is so interesting to teach them the craft because at that age so much of fiction seems mystical, as if there are no rules and no formula. It's nice to encounter the innocence of untainted eyes, where great stories seem to have come from another world. Hopefully as we get into more of the technical aspect I don't ruin reading for them. I feel like I have still kept that childlike marvel with certain particularly well written books (Blood Meridian for example) and hopefully we can teach them a great deal and have them still retain that as well.

Monday, October 20, 2008

Week 4

Losing two consecutive weeks of teaching, the first due to the 8th grade's slam poet guest speaker and this last week due to our Fall break, we lost a lot of our curriculum. We had planned to workshop the last assignment (writing a metered quatrain with a rhyme scheme) and then to assign a sonnet to synthesize our metrical teaching. However, we had to adapt to time, so today we work-shopped the quatrains as planned and moved directly into free verse. Our last week of teaching poetry is next week, and we assigned twenty lines of free verse OR the sonnet, having briefly taught the structures and ideas of this form. We are also allowing those twenty lines of free verse to be broken essentially into as many poems as the students decide. Our hope is that they will create as many works as they can with this assignment, and maybe even feel as though they could write more.

Today we taught five poems to each class. "A Mayan Astronomer in Hell's Kitchen" by Martin Espada, "Thin Ice" by Gary Snider, "perfect white teeth" by Charles Bukowski, and "Sure Signs" and "A Summer Night" by Ted Kooser. While we talked a lot about the freedom of free verse, I think we did our best to impart the idea that free verse poems usually have a structure of meaning, although they don't adhere to any strict form. Our first class did a good job work-shopping each other's work, though we only got through several poems before we went into free verse. Both classes did a good job of analyzing the poems we taught, though things were smoother in the first class. In the second class, instead of work-shopping, some of the students read poems they had written in other classes after hearing our guest speaker two weeks ago. These poems were very good; one of the obstacles I found in work-shop was critiquing these poems because they were so emotionally loaded. Several of the students were moved to tears reading them and reading to each other. Aidan and I gave as much structural input as we thought was appropriate, but being slam poems and being extremely close to the students, we withheld a lot of the teaching here, and I think for the better because the accomplishment the students felt at writing something moving inspired them, I think, to work harder for the rest of the class.

Friday, October 17, 2008

Week 4

After, reprimanding the students in all three of my classes for forgetting pencils (and thus violating their contracts *wink*) I gave them the promised 15 minutes to finish their brainstorming. I then passed out pre-made panels for them to pencil in. It's a good thing that I'm doing trial comics before letting the students start their final ones because in every class there was a decent discrepancy among the amounts of time each student needed. Some of them finished the pencil and started to ink while others had only begun their first panels toward the end of class.

While they worked, I met with each table to show them inking techniques to vary the line width and also achieve a good black and white balance. I also demonstrated how to use the pencil lines as a guide for the ink but to use smooth movements rather than follow the pencil exactly; they would erase the pencil later so it was more important not to have jagged ink lines.

The reduced amount of class structure was not a problem for the majority of the students. Few wanted to be interrupted to explain their work to me and were very productive. The only issue I had was a table of third grade girls who couldn't stop gossiping. I only asked them for "more writing, less talking" a couple of times. When the last half hour flew by faster than the girls expected, and they realized just how little they had completed compared to the other table, the lesson in time management spoke for itself. I don't expect to have a problem with the chit-chat next week.

I'm preparing a packet entitled "The Icing on the Cake" for next week. It's going to compile symbols, stylized markings, shapes, fonts, and any type of design element that will help the students use the language of comics to tell their stories. I want to go over it for a few minutes at the beginning of the class and then give them the rest of the time to brainstorm for their final comics. I'm going to take each student aside to discuss their ideas and make sure they have really strong characters.

And I really am going to give that pop quiz.

Friday, October 10, 2008

Week 3

I have the feeling I'm really going against the spirit of blogging by writing three time-sensitive posts all at once. I shall fix this in future posts...just as long as I don't ever need to start "twittering."

Week three started with me bringing in some of my own work as well as all of my cartooning supplies. I wanted to show the students where all of the background work was headed. I briefly explained to them my creative process: brainstorming, sketching out thumbnails, penciling out all the panels and gutters, then penciling in all the scenes, characters, and speech bubbles, and finally going back through and inking in the finished piece with a brush or quill. Five minutes later, I passed out a guided brainstorming packet to get them started on the process themselves.

I decided to start with the premise "two ants find a crumb" and framed the process in the form of "things to ask yourself."

Here is a transcript of the packet:

1.) About the crumb: What is my crumb made of? Is it a type of food or something else like play dough? How big is it? How heavy is it? What shape is it? What color is it? Does it smell? How does it taste?

2.) About the ants: How many legs do my ants have? What shape are their bodies? What do their eyes look like? Are they wearing shoes? Are they wearing sunglasses or hats or neck ties? Are they the same size or is one ant bigger than the other? What are their personalities like? Is one ant mean? Is one ant nice? Are the ants brave?

3.) About the setting: Where do my ants find the crumb? Inside? Outside? In the grass? In the cushions of a couch? On a kitchen counter? On the sidewalk? On a picnic blanket?

4.) About what happens: What do my ants do with the crumb? Do they discuss it together? Do they try to lift it? Do they climb on it? Do they fight over it? Do they try to take a bite of it? Do they shape it into something? Where do the ants take the crumb? Do they make it where they are going? Does something happen to them and the crumb on the way?

Throughout the packet, I gave them space to both write and draw their answers to the questions, and, at the end, I gave them six "thumb nails" to fill in with an outline of the story.

This exercise worked well. By focusing on the crumb and ants early on, the setting and plot both fell into place easily. I know I've used the word sophistication already, but that's exactly what many of the thumb nails the students sketched had: the stories sprang to life based upon how the characteristics of the ants would cause them to react to the crumb. Here are just a few examples: A pair of hippie ants shared a steak crumb in a fancy Parisian restaurant, a Mexican ant and a scared ant came across rat poison in a grandfather clock and fed it to an unsuspecting (and by the last thumbnail dead) rat, brother ants fought over the crumb until one began to cry and they decided to share it, one exceptionally resourceful ant melted the crumb down and used it to power his rocket ship and spend the rest of the thumbnails going on outer-space adventures. As you can see, some made more sense than others, but overall most every student had a creative story to tell. And these are just examples from the Third Grade.

With fifteen minutes remaining in class, I handed out a blank version of the packet and told the students they would be brainstorming their own practice comic before we started the final ones. I only gave them two rules: no more than two characters and one object. Forty-five minutes a week doesn't allow for graphic novels and despite my desire for quantity in ideas in the brainstorming phase, I wanted to began the process of self-editing so that the students could produce a concise, yet satisfying comic by the end of the session.

In week four, I plan to allow them fifteen more minutes to brainstorm their practice comic, and then I am going to hand out pre-made panels for them to pencil in the comic. Were it not for the time crunch, I would have liked to allow them to be more creative with the panel shapes and sizes, but there's plenty of time for that when they do their final comics. Frankie already acquired thin black markers for me so if the students finish early they'll be able to go over their pencil with ink. I hope that even though I'm giving the students so much time to work on only one thing they'll still be able to stay focused. I think I'll have them discuss their comic with a partner every ten minutes or so to help them check and see if it makes sense and to keep the in-between talking to a minimum.

I was also thinking of handing out a pop quiz just to keep them on their toes.

Week 2

This week focused on character development. The previous week I'd asked the students to bring in a favorite comic (from a book, newspaper, or online) if they wanted. I also brought in several of my own. I started by passing out sheets of lined paper, and after describing a character from one of the comics of their choosing in as much detail as possible out loud, I had them write down either a paragraph or a list with enough concrete descriptions of their characters' physical appearances and personalities so that I'd be able to identify them later. I collected these and was happy to see that almost all of the students had written with great specificity.

I then handed out eight-page packets on character development. The first page showed how to draw proportions and then warp those proportions, the second gave ideas on how to create a character using clothes, props, body language, and facial expressions, the third showed how to draw a "cute" character, the fourth a "villainous" character, the fifth a "goofy" character, the sixth showed how to give a character a line of action, and the seventh and eighth contained lots of ideas for faces. I have to give great thanks to Tom Chalkley for supplying these pages to me. I knew there was a lot in this packet for an elementary school student, but I wanted to give them an excellent reference for creating their characters. The students loved them.

Next, I did a quick exercise showing them how to draw proportions (again using the chalkboard) by demonstrating how to sketch out eight lines and space out the head, neck, arms, etc. I didn't want to spend too long on teaching them how to draw; the beauty of comics is that one can tell a thoughtful story using just stick figures. I'm hoping to achieve a nice balance between using pictures and words to convey ideas. Hopefully, without having to explicitly tell them, the students are picking up on the relationship between the two. After they had drawn a proportional person, I passed out a sample of a cartoon character study by a particularly whimsical cartoonist and had them come up with three their own original characters.

I emphasized putting just as much detail into their character drawings as they had to their paragraphs at the start of class. I asked them a lot of questions as they worked: If your character is mad all the time, how would you show that in his or her face? In the body language? I even had the kids model different emotions for each other: Show the other kids at your table how you look when you're scared. Show them an action that someone who plays sports would do.

My favorites include a plaid banana with five legs, an egg-man with raccoon eyes and flails for arms, a jar of pickles named Picks, a tricked-out chainsaw with arms and legs, teenage bacterium, a spoon with legs (and nothing else), and a series of characters made out of springs and one eye. So far so good. Especially considering they had about ten minutes with which to work.

I'm hoping that by having emphasized dialogue and character the first two weeks, by the time we were writing full comics, all of their stories would be character-driven and detail-heavy. I suppose one could argue against this, but I'm hoping by focusing on these two elements of creative writing, the plots and settings will naturally emerge. It seemed to work really well in week three when I combined the two to brainstorm a trial comic with the students, but we'll see what happens in their final pieces.

On a side-note, I thought I might introduce them to a new comic each week to give them ideas, so I read Edward Gorey's The Wuggly Ump, which is a great little comic written in heroic couplets about a monster and some unsuspecting children. I didn't think it was particularly frightening but several wide-eyed kids asked me if I was sure the monster wasn't real when I'd finished and asked me not to read any more in the following weeks. They told me it was because they would rather use the time to write but I suspect otherwise.

Week 1

Whoever said they were the slacker shouldn't feel any shame as I am just now posting three weeks worth of blog today.

I teach three classes each Wednesday morning starting with Fifth Grade and meandering through Fourth until finally reaching Third. I have 27 kids in entirety and they are all learning to write comics. We meet in the art teacher's office and have two round tables and ten chairs. The upside to this is that the art teacher is in and out all the time and supplies me with any resources that I need. On the downside, I can write on her chalkboard only if I don't mind smearing my entire right half with orange from a rusty filing cabinet. This wouldn't be a downside if the student's weren't always asking me to draw examples of slices of cake, monkeys, and submarines for them to reference.

I have only one goal in my classroom management: to make sure that my students are writing nearly every minute of each forty-five minute class. It's not about keeping them occupied or holding their attention; rather, it's about prioritizing the time for their generation of ideas. There's probably a more eloquent way of saying it, but when I tell the student's they have fifteen minutes to write a collaborative dialogue, they really hit the ground running and come up with some fantastically creative work. When you're brainstorming for inspiration and innovation in writing, quality emerges from quantity.

As was suggested to me, I avoid over planning and give five minutes of direction at most. I spend most of the time going from student to student to discuss their work individually or answering questions as they arise. I don't assign homework but do expect them to complete several in-class writing assignments every week. I collect one or two of them and add them to a portfolio that I will return to each student at the end of the session.

The first week all that we focused on was dialogue. I passed out packets of speech balloons and had the students fill them in with conversations between two characters of their choosing. We discussed how to convey who a character is by not only what they say, but how they say it. I showed them an example of a panel from TinTin in which a reporter has a lot of words crammed into one speech bubble to show that he is talking very fast. We also discussed how to make sure the responses made sense and allowed the conversation to flow. When I felt they understood the process, I passed out blank sheets of paper and gave them five more minutes to write their own conversations. These I collected.

Upon review at home, I discovered the conversations ranged from one between talking muffins to one between General Londo and his brother to one between two unnamed characters about a woman's car blowing up. So far so good. And that was just Fifth Grade. There really is no noticable difference in the ability of a Fifth Grader and a Third Grader to produce ideas. Often, I've found that the Third Graders do better; they seem to have little check on their imaginations. Their only limitation seems to be a greater frequency of miss-spelled words and shorter sentences. (Which, in the world of comics, aren't really limitations at all)

For the last assignment I made the kids pair up with a fellow student from the other table (gasp - the only two boys in my Fifth Grade class had sat at the same table). They were to take turns writing speech bubbles to form a coherent conversation in the remaining fifteen minutes of class. These I also collected.

Here, I could have given the students more direction. Without a goal to work toward with the conversation, quite a few of the dialogues rambled. Discussing likes and dislikes seemed to be a popular choice. Granted, as I kid most of my conversations followed that vector too, but I was looking for more creativity in the subject matter. In the following weeks I made sure to be more explicit with my directions. I realize my expections are high, but if you were come to any of my classes you would have no doubt that my students could, and do, meet them.

Even in the failures of this assignment, the students were able to mine a great deal of learning from it. This can be seen in one particularly unsuccessful dialogue:

S1: "You stink! I hate you!"
S2: "Well you are to!"
S1: "Let's move on to another subject!"
S2: "Okay!"
S1: "What time do you go to bed?"

I was reading over the students' shoulders while this was being written and had them pause to discuss whether any one would actually say that in real life. While I assured them that insults were perfectly appropriate in comics, the transition to the question didn't work. We later brainstormed ideas on how they could say the same thing in way wouldn't seem so unnaturally abrupt.

Overall, using speech bubbles worked really well for all of the grades. It allowed them to organize quite sophisticated conversations they might not have otherwise been able to write in essay form. and were a good launching off point for the weeks to come.

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Week 3

This week class was canceled because of an grade-wide assembly, which I was lucky enough to catch. The 8th grade principle introduced the speaker saying Ms. Gloria, a slam poet from Baltimore, helped her, three years ago, to overcome her son's sudden death through poetry. The principle had started to write following her 30 year old son's shooting, from point blank range outside of a nightclub in downtown Baltimore, and after being paralyzed with grief for nearly a year, she was able, with help, to return to her duties at school.

Ms. Gloria's poetry I think inspired the kids better than our classes have been doing. There was something about the way she was engaging them- she didn't try to teach, and slam poetry relies on performance and not form, sounding out more like hip hop lyrics with alliteration and style than with the meter in which it is delivered. I think the performance aspect- the fact that she was a show was important.

Ms. Gloria was also a story. She was black, mid 40's, medium build, pregnant. She described her first marriage and her drug addict husband in detail, recalling tearfully the night when she left him after he attacked her, junked out, while she was holding her two week old daughter. I think the kids, some of whom I've begun to talk with and who have stories of their own, were taken by her honesty and the fact that she's created something of her woes, something valuable and something that others can identify with. It's nice to see poetry put to use this way. And after crying, the kids were hysterical as Ms. Gloria moonwalked across the stage and described how different she was from Michael Jackson. She said, let me count the ways.

Week 2

Aidan summed things up pretty well in his entry. I just wanted to add a few of my own observations.

It's a shame that when we met the kids from our second class, they thought someone had made a mistake and didn't understand why they were there. I think that for these kids to be shocked by the fact that we were pulling them out of their normal classes and to even go so far as to view it as punishment (not that our teaching is punishment, I hope it's a step up at least, but that they thought they had done something wrong to deserve special treatment) says a lot about the way that remedial education goes (does it have to? really, I don't know).

The kids in our first class are all really interested in fantasy, which I guess is hard for me to identify with now, but at that age, I remember eating up Brian Jaques' books or the Foundation series.

It was hilarious what the kids chose to write about for their Haiku. Aidan and I were trying to teach the classes about traditional Haiku subjects like the season, loneliness, meditation and contemplation, etc. Some of the things we got, though, were rad skateboarding Haiku about Bam Margera and Tony Hawk or just shredding more generally on skates. We got poems about seasons- which let us know that we were getting through a little bit. But it was also cool, because the Haiku is such a minimalist snapshot form, to see just a glimpse into the heads of our kids. Soccer, pizza- what else is on their minds?

Monday, October 6, 2008

Weeks 2 and 3

Technically it is now week 3 for our writing courses, but as the entire sixth grade is on a field trip on Wednesday my classes for the week are cancelled… thus, this post is about what we did in class last week, and I will post again after our meeting on week 4.

Last week I had my first meeting with my morning class, and afterwards met again with the afternoon (Ingenuity) class. I prepared the same lesson plan for both classes (I decided to skip Freytag with the morning kids and get them started on ghost stories asap), focusing the first half of each class on brainstorming ideas. I drew up a brainstorming worksheet (in the shape of a spider web… gotta stick with my scary theme here) and asked the students to fill the innermost boxes with character ideas (names of people, their characteristics/personalities, types of monsters/ghosts/swamp creatures that would appear in the story, etc). From there, they worked their way out through the “boxes” of the web (really just spaces in between the “threads”), filling middle boxes with ideas for setting, mysteries/conflicts of the stories (this tied in with the lesson from last week for my afternoon kids, and I encouraged them to think about Freytag’s pyramid and the importance of conflict/climax/resolution), etc. The outermost boxes were for their ideas about the main events in the stories, the conclusion, any crazy twists or other details they wanted to jot down. They also had space to brainstorm a title at the top. All the students in both classes had ten minutes to work on these worksheets (after I went over all the possibilities for filling in the boxes), and then we discussed in class their ideas for each category (I also assured them that if they had new/different ideas or changed their minds about anything in the web that that was totally cool—this was just meant to get the creative juices flowing, not as a concrete proposal for a story idea).

There was definitely a difference between the ideas generated by the morning class and those of the afternoon class, but all of them were fantastic, impressive and very creative—especially the new morning kids (I was getting plot ideas like “my story is about crazy fruits that have teeth and eat people in the middle of the night”… awesome!) Almost every single student in both classes participated and helped generate a list of ideas on the board, gearing everyone up for some creative scary stories with all the components of a complete short piece.

Finally, I gave them the remainder of the class (about 20 minutes) as writing time to begin their rough drafts, but I had one more twist in store for them (just in case the brainstorm activity had still left some students at a loss for ideas, or even just to shake things up for them): on little slips of paper I printed out Halloween themed story prompts that they picked out of a bag. These included some more general prompts (“I entered the haunted house and screamed when I saw…”) and also some that were more challenging (“I looked down and realized with horror what was floating in my soup: a gigantic…”), and the students were encouraged to find a way to tie these sentence starters into their stories somehow (I challenged them to take their ideas about killer fruits and find a way to include a vampire in a cave from their prompt, hoping to spark even greater creativity). They do not have to use the prompts if they don’t want to; I don’t want to limit their creativity, but I hope they can adapt their stories to meet the challenge. Most of the kids were excited about this extra detail and everyone got started on their pieces (which we will share and continue in week 4).

All in all, I’m really happy with the direction of the course thus far. I have only graded some of the fairy tales from my afternoon class but for the most part these kids are quite gifted. I’m looking forward to hearing preliminary versions of their horror stories next week and also helping them develop interesting, dynamic characters through some worksheets and brainstorms about the characters themselves.

Sunday, October 5, 2008

Week 2

Yes, I am the slacker. It should surprise no one. It should also surprise no one that it does not at all reflect the environment or structure of the class. Really, I swear it doesn't. And to prove it here is a summary of all the work Tom and I have done.

So Tom and I were given two classes to teach once a week. Both classes are 8th graders who are do it in lieu of their language arts class on Mondays (as a side not, what is with all the frivolous names given to English classes in this day and age). The first class is 11 students that are enrolled in the Ingenuity track of Roland Park Middle School. Apparently there are 3 distinct tracks that Roland Park kids get placed on in middle school. The Ingenuity track is a track that the kids have to test into in order to take advanced math and science classes. They are the cream of the crop and they all end up going to Baltimore Polytech or whatever the good magnet school is called and they go on to good colleges and obtain employment as doctors and lawyers and all the other society building good Samaritan vocations that Tom and I will never hold. The second class is full of the more remedial kids. There are only 8 of them so there are less to handle but they have not been exposed to a lot of the stuff Tom and I have been trying to teach.

The structure Tom and I have been imposing on the class is as follows. We are spending the first 5 weeks on poetry where Tom is taking the reigns, and then the last 5 weeks are for fiction where I will be taking over. Each class we start with workshopping what their assignment was the week before. Then we lecture for a little. Then we discuss the reading they were assigned in terms of the lecture information we have given them and then at the end we try to do some more writing and give them their reading and assignments for the next week. Our goal is to have them do a small amount of reading and a small amount of writing each week while also trying to provide them with concrete information in class time that they can use for their own work.

The first class we explained Haikus, read some examples and then had them write their own. We assigned them two Robert Frost poems to read (After Apple Picking and Stopping By Woods on a Snowy Eve). The second class we workshopped their own haikus and then did a small lecture on meter and rhyme. It was good because none of the kids had read Frost and they seemed to enjoy it (albeit to varying degrees). We assigned them two Shakesperean sonnets and asked that they write 4 iambic pentameter lines and that they scan their own lines for correctness (i.e. illustrate the stresses and divide the feet). We will see if they actually partake in this or if they finally develop the courage to blow us off.

The advanced class that we teach is great. They are like little college kids. They sit around quietly when we lecture and generally humor us in all our ridiculousness. They raise their hands when they want to talk and they are getting over the shyness of reading their own work. Also, there is this really quiet girl who sits in the back who is a poetry all star. The Haiku's she wrote were amazing and she seems to know everything we teach her. She is really reluctant to participate however, as it seems that she gets made fun of in class. We learned this in the first class when she said her favorite books were on necromania and once I stupidly explained what this was to the class (I told them it was books about zombies) they flipped and we had to lecture about class respect. Tom and I have been trying to get her engaged, and hopefully she will come out of her shell once we get to the serious writing. Tomorrow we are going to talk about sonnet structure and have them write their own, and assign them some free verse and prose poetry to read in order get a few more styles in.

The second class is a little more difficult for us. They have a much shorter attention span for our lectures so we try to fill more of the time with workshopping and writing in class. The problem is that only 2 or 3 regularly do their work so we don't have anything to workshop. We have been flirting with introducing some positive reinforcement to get them to do work (like candy, the great equalizer) but we are going to decide after we see how many did the writing for tomorrow. They don't do the reading as much as the first class, but they aren't nearly as shy. They fight to read out loud and to read their own writing out loud. The enthusiasm is there, just not the discipline. We are also going to try to bring in more poetry to read in class because that really really gets them excited. The struggle is keeping them engaged and we are flirting with the idea of changing the subject matter with them, but neither of us like the idea of teaching down to them because they definitely understand what we are saying, they just don't really care about it.

All in all it has been a blast so far. No disciplinary problems and we are getting better at keeping their attention each week. Everyone seems to enjoy it and they have a great creative spirit where they feel free to write about anything and everything, no matter how crazy. My only hope is that they don't get it beaten out of them by the time they finish high school like I did. I remember my first foray into creative writing was in 9th grade where I wrote an opus about a kid who gets stranded in Antarctica and when I turned it in, the teacher said, "Aidan, the number one rule of writing is to write what you know." I vowed to these kids on the first day I would never say anything like that to them because in my opinion that makes for insanely boring writing, as evidenced by the number of teenage love stories that I read for workshop, and it has been great so far. One kid wrote a Haiku set about a sinking ship, one kid wrote about playing football, one girl wrote about dating Obama. It's great to see that creative energy that hasn't gotten coopted by talk of 'realism' and 'veracity.' It's been very encouraging and hopefully the rest of the semester goes as well as it has so far.

Saturday, September 27, 2008

Okay well I guess I'm the first to post about my teaching experience so here goes!

Wednesday I had my first class with a group of top sixth graders. I decided to have them read a short piece in class so that we could talk about plot structure and Freytag's pyramid and I could gauge their reading level. I chose about 8 pages from The Hobbit (which is of course a longish book but each chapter is basically its own isolated story), because I wanted to show that a short story isn't just finished whenever the author FEELS like ending it or because the teacher photocopied it that way, but that a short story is complete and well constructed if it contains the 6 elements of plot (exposition, conflict, rising action, climax, falling action, resolution). In this way, even a segment taken from a larger story can be complete on its own so long as it has these six elements (ie, the part where Bilbo fights off the giant spiders is a good stand-alone story because it follows the pyramid). I was a little nervous that the material I picked out for them would be too challenging (I chose The Hobbit because I read it myself in 6th or 7th grade and absolutely loved it, but online sources told me that it is classified as a 9-10 grade reading level), but I was so pleasantly surprised at how it turned out.

I was so happy about how bright and enthusiastic these kids were; not only had half of them already read The Hobbit, but when I asked for volunteers to read aloud every single hand shot up. Almost all of them were flawless readers, and all were eager to participate as I drew diagrams on the board and asked them to identify the 6 elements of plot structure in Cinderella (I chose an example of a story everyone would know), and, after finishing the segment from The Hobbit, they didn't miss a beat in matching the elements in that story to the pyramid guideline as well. After this I handed out a nifty worksheet I found online that lets students fill in the different sections of the pyramid (as well as things like "theme" and "protagonist"), and although I had originally planned on having them fill this in for the reading from The Hobbit, I decided that in the interest of getting them started on their actual writing ASAP, I would have them use the worksheet as an outline/brainstorm sheet to write their own short fairy tale. I hope that planning out their stories based on the pyramid will help them write a more complete short story.

So now that I have assessed their reading level and know what to expect in terms of their writing, I'm set to begin the first big project with them on Wednesday (the fairy tale assignment was just a short piece for them to practice writing with the 6 elements). Starting next week I'm going to take them through all the stages of short story writing with the theme of Ghost Stories, and the goal will be for all students to prepare a final draft for the last class before Halloween (October 29), and on that day we'll have a horror-fest story reading with candy and prizes for the scariest stories. I told the students about this plan and they seemed really excited!

Soo that's all, so far so good! I'll post again next weekend!

-Sarah Jane